QUOTE(Matt Ottinger @ May 14 2008, 02:25 PM) [snapback]185999[/snapback]
However, their oddly inconsistent judging was on display today. In the same Puzzle, 'Dizziness' was accepted for the Password 'Dizzy', but 'Doctor' was not accepted for the Password 'Doc'
I don't see that as inconsistent. Dizziness is a form of the word dizzy. Doctor is not a form of the word doc. (That is to say, in the two dictionaries I consulted as I wrote this, "doc" and "doctor" were actually two separate entries, whereas "dizziness" was, in both dictionaries, listed under "dizzy".)
Now that said, using "doc" as a password is almost as bad of an idea as using "New York" as a password.