QUOTE(Modor @ Jan 22 2008, 11:23 PM) [snapback]175952[/snapback]
Well, let me ask this much. Let's say the word is "Board Game". If they say "game", and then several seconds after, they say "board", they'd sound the bell?
My first instinct is that there's no difference between 'bow and arrow' and 'arrow and bow', however there is a difference between 'game board' and 'board game' so your contrarian analogy isn't as precise as perhaps you were hoping and therefore not really relevant to this particular example.
The interesting thing about the Pyramid judge is that he judged. There were guidelines, as there should be, but ultimately the judge decided right there on the spot whether or not to accept an answer. To my knowledge, only one member of this forum has ever actually been a judge on a Pyramid TV show, and he hasn't contributed to this thread. We could sit around all day making up 'would they accept this?' scenarios, but each one would be a different case, and ultimately we're all just guessing what might have happened.